September 10, 2026
Life Insurance Tax Issues Every Taxpayer Should Know
Most people think of life insurance as simple protection for their family. And it is. But life insurance can also create surprising tax issues when the policy builds cash value, is borrowed against, is surrendered, is sold, or pays out early because the insured is terminally or chronically ill.
The good news is that life insurance is often tax-favored. In many cases, the growth inside the policy is not taxed each year, and death benefits are generally excluded from income. But the tax rules can change a lot depending on the type of policy and what happens to it during the insured’s lifetime.
Basis: The term basis is used throughout this article. Whenrelated to life insurance, it is generally the total amount of money you have paid into the policy through premiums.
Two Big Categories – Non-MEC and MEC: One of the most important tax questions is whether the policy is a modified endowment contract (MEC) or a non-MEC. A MEC is a policy that fails the tax code’s “7-pay” test because it was funded too quickly, usually with larger premiums than a typical life insurance policy would allow over the first seven years.
- Why Does That Matter?
o A non-MEC is usually the more tax-friendly version during life.
o A MEC still provides life insurance protection, but withdrawals and loans are taxed much less favorably.
o In a MEC, taxable amounts are treated as income first, and policy loans are treated as distributions.
o A 10% additional tax can apply to taxable distributions made before age 59½ in some situations. - Why Non-MEC Policies Are Usually Preferred - A non-MEC policy generally allows the owner to access cash value more favorably. The policy’s growth, often called inside buildup, is generally not taxed while the policy stays in force.
When money comes out of a non-MEC policy during the insured’s life, the general rule is:
1. The owner recovers basis first.
2. Only amounts above basis are taxable.
In plain English, that means the premiums you paid usually come out first tax-free, and only later does taxable income begin.
Example - Non-MEC Withdrawal: Suppose you paid $60,000 in premiums over the years and later withdraw $40,000 from a non-MEC policy. If your basis is at least $40,000, that withdrawal is generally tax-free because you are simply getting back part of what you put in. - Why MECs Can Create Surprise Taxes - A MEC is still a valid life insurance contract, but the tax treatment is harsher. Once a policy becomes a MEC:
o distributions are taxed income first,
o loans are treated as distributions, and
o a 10% additional tax (aka penalty) may apply to taxable amounts before age 59½.
That means a policyowner who thinks they are “just borrowing against cash value” may actually be triggering taxable income.
Example - MEC loan: If a policyholder borrows from a MEC at age 50, the loan is generally treated as a taxable distribution rather than a tax-free loan, and will be subject to an “early distribution” penalty. That can create an unexpected tax bill.
Death Benefits Are Still Generally Tax-free: Even if a policy is a MEC, the death benefit is generally excluded from gross income when it is paid because of the insured’s death.
So the MEC rules mainly affect what happens during life, not the basic tax-free treatment of the death benefit itself.
Selling a Life Insurance Policy Can Create Taxes: Sometimes people sell a life insurance policy instead of surrendering it. This is often called a life settlement.
The tax result depends on whether the policy has cash value or not. For a policy with cash value, the seller may have both:
- ordinary income, and
- capital gain.
The IRS treatment is based on the idea that part of the sale price replaces income the owner would have recognized if the policy had simply been surrendered.
- Policy With Cash Value - If a policy has cash value and is sold, the gain is often split:
o The portion equal to cash surrender value minus premiums paid is ordinary income, and
o Any extra amount above that is long-term capital gain.
Example - Sale of a cash-value policy: If a taxpayer paid $64,000 in premiums and sells the policy for $80,000, part of the $16,000 gain may be ordinary income and the rest capital gain, depending on the surrender-value calculation.
- What About a Term Policy? A term life policy usually has no cash value. If that kind of policy is sold, the gain or loss is generally capital in nature, and the seller’s basis is generally the premiums paid.
Example - Sale of term policy: If someone paid $45,000 in premiums for a term policy and sells it for $20,000, the result may be a capital loss, although the loss may not always be deductible on the tax return.
Basis Is Usually Just the Premiums Paid: For tax purposes, the adjusted basis of a life insurance contract is generally the amount of premiums paid.
A major law change in 2009 clarified that basis is not reduced for mortality, expense, or other reasonable charges under the contract. That can make a real difference in determining gain or loss when a policy is sold or surrendered.
Accelerated Death Benefits: Some policies allow the insured to receive money before death if the person is terminally ill or chronically ill. These are called accelerated death benefits.
In general, these amounts can be excluded from income if the insured meets the rules for terminal illness or chronic illness.
- Terminally Ill - A terminally ill person is generally someone certified by a physician as expected to die within 24 months.
- Chronically Ill - A chronically ill person is generally someone certified by a licensed health care practitioner as needing help with certain daily living activities or supervision for severe cognitive impairment.
For chronically ill individuals, the exclusion can be limited depending on how the benefit is paid and what it is used for.
Viatical Settlements: A viatical settlement is the sale or assignment of a life insurance contract on the life of a terminally or chronically ill person.
If the transaction qualifies, the payment may be excluded from income. This is one of the most favorable tax rules in the life insurance area.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers: Here are the main things to remember:
- Check Whether the Policy is a MEC - That affects how withdrawals and loans are taxed.
- Track Your Premiums - Premiums are usually the basis in the policy.
- Don’t Assume Policy Loans are Always Tax-Free - That is usually true for non-MECs, but not for MECs.
- Be Careful When Selling a Policy - A sale can create both ordinary income and capital gain.
- Ask About Illness-Related Benefits - Accelerated death benefits and viatical settlements may be excluded if the insured qualifies.
Bottom Line
Life insurance can be an excellent financial tool, but the tax result depends on what kind of policy you have and what you do with it. Non-MEC policies generally offer the most favorable lifetime tax treatment. MECs are still valid insurance, but they are taxed more harshly during life. Sales of policies can create a mix of ordinary income and capital gain. And if the insured is terminally or chronically ill, special exclusion rules may apply.
For questions related to your specific circumstances contact this office.
Printable PDF